Well I just finished watching Michael Moore's "Sicko." And, while I hate to use such a trite expression, it truly made me sick. It made me heartsick to watch the stories of Americans who have lost everything, even their lives, because they got screwed over by the American health care system.The first few moments of the film were grotesquely disturbing. First, there was the guy who was shown sewing up a gash in his own leg. Then, the story of a man who cut off two fingers in a saw accident. It was going to cost $60,000 to reattach his middle finger, but only $12,000 to reattach his ring finger. He chose the ring finger because that's all he could afford.
These two guys are part of the 50 million unemployed Americans. But the story is not about them. It's about the 250 million Americans who rest comfortably in the belief that if they get sick, they will be taken care of. Sicko blows the lid off that myth.
They did interviews with former Medical Directors, physicians who's job is to review cases and deny as many claims as possible. Their performance, and subsequent pay increases and bonus, is graded on the number of denials they process. One Medical Director admitted that she denied a claim for a necessary operation and the patient died.
The Hippocratic Oath states, "I will apply dietetic measures to benefit the sick, according to my ability and judgment; I will keep them from harm and injustice." How the hell can a physician who took this oath work in a position where the financial interests of the insurance company are placed over the health of the patient?
There were many other stories. A mother in LA who rushed her newborn daughter to the nearest hospital when she developed a 104 fever. The hospital refused to treat the child because Kaiser Permanente said she wouldn't be covered unless she was treated at a company-owned hospital. During the time it took to transport the little girl, she went into cardiac arrest and died.
And then there was the story of the Kansas City father who died from cancer because his insurance denied a bone marrow transplant because it was "experimental." His claim was denied even though his younger brother was a perfect bone marrow match, and doctors insisted he had a good chance of getting well if he had the transplant.
A 22 year old Michigan woman was denied coverage for treatment of cervical cancer because of her age. She was told 22 year old women don't get cervical cancer.
A middle-aged couple went bankrupt and lost everything after she developed cancer and he had 3 heart attacks. All the fine print in their insurance policies guaranteed that they would have to sell their home and move into their daughter's basement.
Then there was the young lady who was injured in a car accident. She was unconscious when the ambulance arrived. The insurance company denied the claim for the ambulance because it hadn't been pre-approved. How the hell can you call for approval when you're unconscious????? Actually, she was the lucky one in this group.
The answer to this mess would seem to be some sort of national health care for all. But, of course, the right-wingers scare us off with the specter of "socialized medicine." They tell us, "how would you like it to be like Canada or Europe, where people are dying in waiting rooms for lack of care?" Well, that is a scary thought. The problem is, it is an absolute lie.
Moore takes us to Canada, and speaks with several Canadian citizens about the benefits of their medical system. None of them would trade their health care for ours. They are able to go to any doctor, go to any hospital, are treated without regard to payment, and never receive a bill.
Their hospitals are high-tech, with all the bells and whistles of any American hospital. And the medical staff is concerned about the health of the patient, not who is going to pay for it. The same thing was found in England and France. And isn't it interesting that statistics show that people with "socialized medicine" have longer average lifespans, lower infant mortality rates, and better overall health than the average American.
The most poignant moment was when Moore took a group of Americans to Cuba. These were special Americans. They were EMT's who had volunteered to work at ground zero after 9/11. They subsequently developed respiratory ailments that affected their ability to work. Their workers comp claims were all denied because because they weren't "on the job" when they were injured. They gave their all, and the system took it all from them.
So, Moore takes them to a hospital in Havana, where they are admitted and treated, and they all received suitcases full or prescriptions and treatment plans for when they returned home. All of this without payment, and without regard to their citizenship. It brought tears to my eyes watching these Cuban doctors and nurses caring for these American heroes that had been rejected by their own system.
To be honest, I've never had any major problems with my insurance. But, I am one of the lucky ones. I only pay $30 a paycheck for my medical. I've never had any serious medical issues. But I also recognize that "there but for the grace of God go I." Those of us with cushy company group plans are only one job loss away from being destitute.
I know the Bill O'Reilly's of the world will call this another socialist propaganda piece from socialist Michael Moore. But health care for all will be right up there with global warming as THE issue of the coming years. I urge everyone to see Sicko and see it with an open mind.


